AI Solutions: Build or Buy Decision Framework

This blog will provide a framework to help you decide. It will guide you in choosing between building or buying AI solutions for your business.

Understanding the Build vs. Buy Decision

The build vs. buy decision comes down to two distinct options:

• Building AI solutions means creating apps for your specific business needs. This is often done by in-house or outsourced development teams.
• Buying AI solutions means getting off-the-shelf AI products. They are pre-designed to perform specific tasks. These include automating customer service, predictive analytics, and optimizing inventory.
  ‍

Each option has its benefits and challenges. The key is to align your choice with your business goals, tech skills, and long-term vision for AI.

The Complexity of Your AI Needs

The complexity of your AI needs is a crucial factor when deciding between building or buying. AI applications can range from simple tools like chatbots to advanced systems. The latter can process huge datasets, predict customer behavior, and optimize supply chains.

• When to Buy: If your needs are simple, an off-the-shelf AI solution might work. For example, it can automate customer service queries or analyze simple data sets. Pre-built solutions are for common tasks. They can be deployed quickly with minimal setup.
• When to Build: If you need specialized AI not in pre-built products, or a system that deeply integrates into your proprietary processes, you may need to build a custom solution. Building allows for a more tailored approach, ensuring the AI aligns perfectly with your business goals.

Time to Value

Time to value refers to how quickly you can deploy an AI solution and start realizing benefits. This factor often influences the build vs. buy decision based on how fast your business needs the solution.

• When to Buy: Off-the-shelf AI solutions can be deployed much faster than building from scratch. If you have tight deadlines or a pressing issue, buy an AI solution. It will improve customer response times and reduce churn. It will offer immediate value. Most pre-built solutions are designed for fast implementation and can often be up and running in a matter of days or weeks.
• When to Build: Building AI solutions takes time. Developing a custom solution may take months—or even longer, depending on the complexity. A custom solution can yield a bigger payoff than a pre-built product. But, it requires a long-term effort and resources to manage.

Costs and Budget

AI solutions, whether built or bought, require significant financial investment. Understanding your budget and the total cost of ownership is key to making the right decision.

• When to Buy: For companies with smaller budgets, buying an off-the-shelf AI solution can often be more cost-effective. There’s no need to hire specialized talent or invest in ongoing development. Additionally, the predictable subscription or licensing costs associated with buying AI solutions can simplify budgeting.
• When to Build: Building your own AI solution involves higher upfront costs. You'll need to invest in AI talent, technology infrastructure, and ongoing maintenance. But building also offers greater control over your costs in the long term. As your AI needs evolve, you won’t have to pay for features you don’t need or scale at the provider’s pricing structure.

Internal Capabilities

Your organization's tech skills are key in deciding to build or buy AI. This involves checking your in-house skills and resources for developing and maintaining AI systems.

• When to Buy: If your team lacks the expertise in AI and machine learning, buying a solution makes more sense. Most vendors provide training and support, and the solutions come ready to use with minimal technical oversight. This lets your team focus on core business activities. They can use AI's benefits without the burden of its complexity.
• When to Build: If you have a strong internal AI team or the capacity to hire and manage one, building your AI solution can be a strategic move. It lets you create a flexible, custom solution. You will control its functions, data, and future development.

Scalability and Flexibility

As your business grows, your AI needs will evolve. Scalability and flexibility should be top of mind when deciding between building or buying an AI solution.

• When to Buy: Pre-built AI solutions are often highly scalable, especially if offered as cloud-based services. If you anticipate growth and need a solution that can easily scale with your business, buying can be an ideal option. However, flexibility may be limited if your AI requirements change significantly over time.
• When to Build: Building your own AI solution offers unmatched flexibility. You can design the system to meet your current needs and adjust as your business evolves. This is especially useful if you foresee significant changes in your industry or business model that might require unique AI capabilities down the line.

Data Security and Compliance

AI thrives on data. So, data security and compliance with regulations (like GDPR or CCPA) are critical.

• When to Buy: Reputable AI providers have strong security and compliance. This can ease concerns about data handling. For many businesses, especially those with limited in-house security expertise, buying an AI solution offers peace of mind knowing that data security is being managed by experts.
• When to Build: If your business handles sensitive data or is in a regulated industry, build your own AI solution. It allows for more control over data security. You can tailor the system to meet stringent regulatory requirements and implement custom security features specific to your industry.

Long-Term Ownership and Control

Lastly, the level of ownership and control you require from your AI system can heavily influence the build vs. buy decision.

• When to Buy: Buying an AI solution means you’re relying on a third-party provider. This can be ideal if you’re looking for a hassle-free solution that you don’t need to manage. However, it also means that you may be limited by the provider’s roadmap, pricing, and feature set. If they change or discontinue a service, your business could be affected.
• When to Build: Building your own AI solution gives you full ownership and control. You aren’t tied to a vendor’s limitations, and you can modify the system as needed. This is vital if your AI solution is a key market differentiator or central to your long-term strategy.

Wrap Up

Deciding whether to build or buy an AI solution is complex. It depends on your business goals, budget, tech skills, and long-term vision. This framework will help you choose wisely. It will align with your company's needs and maximize AI's value in your organization.

Want Help?

We provide expert guidance so you can use AI to lift business performance. The 33A AI Design Sprint™ process is the foundation for our approach. We help you discover the most promising AI use cases, so you can apply AI for massive efficiency gains in your business. Schedule a strategy call to learn more.

Want to catch up on earlier issues? Explore the Hub, your AI resource.

Magnetiz.ai is your AI consultancy. We work with you to develop AI strategies that improve efficiency and deliver a competitive edge.